Tuesday, 29 November 2016

Long Run Growth in Spain: Evidence from Historical National Accounts

Leandro Prados de la Escosura
 (Universidad Carlos III,
CEPR, Groningen, and CAGE)
Can we rely on historical estimates of GDP to assess output and material welfare in the long run? 

In the early days of modern economic quantification, Kuznets (1952: 16-17), noticed the “tendency to shrink from long-term estimates” on the grounds of “the increasing inadequacy of the data as one goes back in time and to the increasing discontinuity in social and economic conditions”. Cautious historians recommend to restrict the use of GDP to societies that had efficient recording mechanisms, relatively centralised economic activities, and a small subsistence sector (Hudson, 2016; Deng and O’Brien, 2016). But should not the adequacy of data be “judged in terms of the uses of the results” (Kuznets, 1952: 17)? 

A new dataset

It is with these caveats that a new set of historical national accounts, with GDP estimates from the demand and supply side, is presented for Spain as the basis to investigate its modern economic growth (Prados de la Escosura, 2016b). 
Historical output and expenditure series are reconstructed for the century prior to the introduction of modern national accounts. The new series are built from highly disaggregated data grounded on the painstaking research carried out during the last decades. 
Then, available national accounts are spliced through interpolation, as an alternative to conventional retropolation, to derive new continuous series for 1958-2015 (Prados de la Escosura, 2014, 2016a). Later, the series for the ‘pre-statistical era’ are linked to the spliced national accounts providing yearly series for GDP and its components over 1850-2015. Finally, on the basis of new population and labour force estimates, GDP per head and labour productivity are derived (the dataset can be accessed at http://espacioinvestiga.org/bbdd-chne/?lang=en)

What do the data show? 

Aggregate economic activity multiplied fifty times between 1850 and 2015, at an average cumulative growth rate of 2.4 per cent per year. Four main phases may be established: 1850-1950 (with a shift to a lower level during the Civil War, 1936-1939), 1951-1974, 1975-2007, and 2008-2015, in which the growth trend varied significantly. 

Figure 1. Real GDP and GDP per head (2010=100) (logs)


But to what extent did a larger amount of goods and services affect individuals’ living conditions? Since population trebled, real GDP per head experienced nearly a 16-fold increase, growing at an annual rate of 1.7 percent. Such an improvement took place at an uneven pace. Per capita GDP grew at 0.7 per cent over 1850-1950, doubling its initial level. During the next quarter of a century, the Golden Age, its pace accelerated more than 7-fold, so by 1974 per capita income was 3.6 times higher than in 1950. Although economic progress slowed down from 1975 onwards, and the rate of per capita GDP growth shrank to one-half that of the Golden Age, the level of per capita GDP more than doubled between 1974 and 2007. The Great Recession (2008-13) shrank per capita income by 11 per cent, but, by 2015, its level was still 83 per cent higher than at the time of Spain’s EU accession (1985).
What steered such a remarkable rise in product per capita? GDP per capita depends on the amount of work per person and how productive this effort is. GDP per capita and labour productivity (measured as GDP per hour worked) evolved alongside over 1850-2015, even though, as the amount of hours worked per person shrank labour productivity grew at a faster pace –it increased 23-fold against 16-fold for GDP per capita. 


Figure 2. Per Capita GDP and its Components, 1850-2015 (2010=100) (logs)

Behind the decline in hours worked per person the main element is the reduction in hours worked per fully occupied worker, which fell from 2,800 hours per year in mid-nineteenth century to less than 1,900 in the early twentieth-first century. Thus, long-term gains in output per capita are entirely attributable to productivity gains, with phases of accelerating GDP per capita, such as the 1920s or the Golden Age (1950-1974), matching those of faster labour productivity growth. 
A closer look at the last four decades reveals, however, significant discrepancies, with phases of acceleration in labour productivity correspond to those of GDP per person slowdown, and vice versa. Thus, periods of sluggish (1975-84) or negative (2008-13) per capita GDP growth paralleled episodes of vigorous or recovering productivity growth, although in the first case, the ‘transition to democracy’ decade, labour productivity offset the sharp contraction in hours worked –largely resulting from unemployment- and prevented a decline in GDP per head. Conversely, the years between Spain’s accession to the European Union (1985) and the eve of the Great Recession (2007), exhibited substantial per capita GDP gains while labour productivity slowed down. Thus, during the three decades after Spain’s accession to the EU, in which grew at 3 per cent per year, doubling its GDP per head, the increase in hours worked per person contributed more than half of it. It can, then, be concluded that since the mid-1970s the Spanish economy has been unable to combine employment creation and productivity growth, with the implication that sectors that expanded and created jobs (mostly construction and services) were those less successful in attracting investment and technological innovation.

Falling behind, catching up, … and falling back again?

Spanish long-term growth has been similar to that of western nations, though Spain’s level of GDP per head appears systematically lower. 


Figure 3. Spain’s Comparative Real Per Capita GDP (2011 EKS $) (logs)


The pace of growth before 1950 was comparatively slow in Spain. Sluggish performance over 1883-1913 and failing to take advantage of its World War I neutrality to catch up, partly account for it. Furthermore, the progress achieved in the 1920s was outweighed by Spain’s short-lived recovery from the Depression, brought to a halt by Civil War (1936-39), and by a longer and weaker post-war reconstruction than in the warring western European countries after 1945. Thus, Spain fell behind between 1850 and 1950. 
The situation reverted from 1950 to 2007. The Golden Age, especially since 1960, stands out as years of outstanding performance and catching up to the advanced nations. Steady, although slower growth after the transition to democracy years (1975-84), allowed Spain to keep catching up until 2007. The Great Recession reversed the trend, although it is too soon to determine whether it has opened a new phase of falling behind. 
On the whole, Spain’s relative position to western countries has evolved along a wide-U shape, deteriorating to 1950 (except for the 1870s and 1920s) and recovering thereafter (but for the episodes of the transition to democracy and the Great Recession). Thus, at the beginning of the twentieth-first century Spanish real GDP per head represented a proportion of US and Germany’s income similar to that of mid-nineteenth century, and to that of the 1870s with regard to France and Italy, although had significantly improved with respect to the UK. 

This blog post was written by Leandro Prados de la Escosura, professor in Economic history at (Universidad Carlos III)

The working paper can be downloaded here: http://www.ehes.org/EHES_103.pdf

References

Deng, K. and P. O’Brien (2016), “China’s GDP Per Capita from the Han Dynasty to Communist Times”, World Economics 17, 2: 79-123.
Hudson, P. (2016), GDP per capita: from measurement tool to ideological construct, LSE Business Review (10 May 2016).
Kuznets, S. (1952), Income and Wealth of the United States. Trade and Structure, Income and Wealth Series II, Cambridge: Bowes and Bowes.
Prados de la Escosura (2016a), “Mismeasuring Long Run Growth. The Bias from Spliced National Accounts: The Case of Spain”, Cliometrica 10, 3: 251-275
Prados de la Escosura, L. (2016b), Spain’s Historical National Accounts: Expenditure and Output, 1850-2015, EHES Working Paper 103 http://www.ehes.org/EHES_103.pdf The dataset can be accessed at http://espacioinvestiga.org/bbdd-chne/?lang=en
Prados de la Escosura, L. (2014), Mismeasuring long-run growth: The bias from spliced national accounts,  (4 September) http://positivecheck.blogspot.se/



45 comments:

  1. Hi admin,
    I read your blog, its really awesome,

    An introduction and overview of the growing field of forensic accounting. Gives a broad information base on what this new and exciting career choice has to offer.

    GTA accountant


    Your regards
    Alfaj Ripon

    ReplyDelete
  2. If you are a business owner facing divorce, the thought of protecting your business from divorce can only add to the stress and strain that you are already going through. Unlike most property or personal assets, your business represents a personal investment of your own time, money, creativity and her response The idea that you might lose something you built because of an unfortunate turn in your personal circumstances can be both frustrating and frightening.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is my very first time i go to here. I discovered a great number of entertaining stuff in your blog site, particularly its discussion. From your tons of feedback in your articles, Pest Control Companies in Abu Dhabi guess I am not the only one possessing each of the satisfaction here! Preserve up the great operate.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I dream of owning my own business and ditching my boss and having enough money to be comfortable. I want to start a business now. What do I do? vladimir vrbaski republika

    ReplyDelete
  5. I visited a lot of website but I conceive this one holds something special in it in it geeksviral

    ReplyDelete
  6. The following time I learn a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I imply, I do know it was my option to learn, however I really thought youd have one thing fascinating to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you can fix when you werent too busy on the lookout for attention. kaspersky internet security activation code for android

    ReplyDelete
  7. Organic raw food is an important part of the raw food diet. Organic food is grown using age old farming techniques that do not require the use of pesticides which can be harmful to both you and the environment. Types of Natural Selection Worksheet

    ReplyDelete
  8. Are you looking information on how to fund a home based business? Here is what you need to know. From risky business to power couple partnership, discover why couples everywhere are learning the secrets to running a successful business together while deepening their relationship. Find out why couple entrepreneurs are building the lifestyle of their dreams and protecting their assets and how you can too, by starting a business, growing your relationship and learning to achieve success together. Contact cash app

    ReplyDelete
  9. At a time of financial distress, the payday or cash advance can be utilised to protect your good credit rating. Not everyone is aware of this opportunity, although companies granting these short-term loans proliferate on the internet. Most are reputable organisations; however, you should be aware that there are a few bad apples in this barrel of pounds. You can protect your best interests by verifying the reputation of the company you plan to apply to. The Better Business Bureau is a good resource to use as they will have a record of any complaints lodged against a business. payday loans ct

    ReplyDelete
  10. The one trait all successful business owners have in common is that they ask for help when they need it. And the good news is help is readily available. You can find a business counselor or coach https://cad.cheapsoftwaredownload.net/ just about any location not far from you and sessions are often at no charge, especially if you're planning to start a business.

    ReplyDelete
  11. In the case of bridging loans, the same rules apply in most cases. However, there are some bridging lenders that will always lend specifically based on the current market value – ignoring what you paid for your property. credit sesame login

    ReplyDelete
  12. Conveyancing… [...]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[...]… palak paneer recipe in gujarati

    ReplyDelete
  13. Cryptocurrencies seem to be the hottest investment products going around. Eavesdrop on any of your friend's conversation, it is about bitcoins. All the workplace chat is also about virtual currencies. buy bitcoin

    ReplyDelete
  14. Free online games… [...]With havin so much content do you ever run into any problems of plagorism or copyright infringement? My website has a lot of completely unique content I’ve either authored myself or outsourced but it looks like a lot of it is popping it up all ov… buying 100 instagram followers

    ReplyDelete
  15. Most appropriate the human race messages work to show your and present exclusive chance with special couple. Beginer appear system in advance of raucous people will most likely always be aware most of the golden value off presentation, which is a person’s truck. best man jokes coreldraw graphics suite 2018 vs x8

    ReplyDelete
  16. I dream of owning my own business and ditching my boss and having enough money to be comfortable. I want to start a business now. What do I do? brokers confiables

    ReplyDelete
  17. Businesses will oftentimes benefit from obtaining business management consulting services. These services are especially advantageous to those businesses that are new to the industry. From marketing strategy development to client management to... effected vs affected

    ReplyDelete
  18. Ready to start your new adventure in business? Here's a starting point to get you on your way. Corporate Consulting Provider

    ReplyDelete
  19. Cash app is a peer to peer payment app that was launched in 2013 by Square Inc, it allows users to send and receive money online. In the Cash app instead of an account number, you are known on the network by your email address or phone number. You can also create a unique identifier known as a $Cashtag. Users can link Cash App to an existing bank account and use that to transfer money to and from the Cash App account. With Cash App, you can send money from a debit card and spend your Cash App balance directly from that. Users can also receive direct deposits (like a paycheck), to their accounts.
    https://helpcashapp.com

    https://helpcashapp.com/about-us

    https://helpcashapp.com/blog

    https://helpcashapp.com/how-to-access-the-old-cash-app-account

    https://helpcashapp.com/how-to-fix-cash-app-not-working

    https://helpcashapp.com/how-to-activate-cash-app-card

    https://helpcashapp.com/how-to-delete-cash-app-account

    https://helpcashapp.com/cash-app-refund

    https://helpcashapp.com/want-to-increase-limit-of-my-cash-app

    ReplyDelete
  20. How To Reset Cash App Pin
    Cash app pin is required for transfer cash from phone and for using cash card, no matter what, you are using android or iPhone. It is quite common to forget the Cash app in the current time when we use multiple apps and the number of passwords and pins have to remember. You can’t transfer money or make a purchase without having Cash app pin. If you have stuck with such an unwanted situation there is no need to worry because reset a cash app pin is such easy as a piece of cake.
    https://cashapphelp.com/blog/how-to-reset-cash-app-pin
    cash app customer service
    want-to-increase-limit-of-my-cash-app
    how-to-check-cash-app-account-balance
    how-to-access-the-old-cash-app-account
    how-to-activate-cash-app-card
    how-to-increase-cash-app-limit



    ReplyDelete
  21. Exiting a business is one of the most important life transitions you will ever make. If you are a baby boomer business owners (ages 55 and up) you simply can't afford to sell your business alone. You need the help of a trusted adviser to see you through the complicated process. Before you hire an expert, however, be sure to do your due diligence and determine if this person is truly working in your best interest. Directory Submission Benefits

    ReplyDelete
  22. Exiting a business is one of the most important life transitions you will ever make. If you are a baby boomer business owners (ages 55 and up) you simply can't afford to sell your business alone. You need the help of a trusted adviser to see you through the complicated process. Before you hire an expert, however, be sure to do your due diligence and determine if this person is truly working in your best interest. http://leadgrowdevelop.com/tips-for-writing-a-successful-business-strategy-for-the-post-covid-business-world/

    ReplyDelete
  23. UAN or Universal Account Number is essential for you to access your PF records and ensure all your savings are being credited to your account. Accessing the UAN Member Portal at www.epfindia.gov.in through your UAN will help you simplify the various tasks that otherwise would have meant visiting your local Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation or EPFO office. EPFIndia.com

    ReplyDelete
  24. Exiting a business is one of the most important life transitions you will ever make. If you are a baby boomer business owners (ages 55 and up) you simply can't afford to sell your business alone. You need the help of a trusted adviser to see you through the complicated process. Before you hire an expert, however, be sure to do your due diligence and determine if this person is truly working in your best interest. barclays public adjusters

    ReplyDelete
  25. Exiting a business is one of the most important life transitions you will ever make. If you are a baby boomer business owners (ages 55 and up) you simply can't afford to sell your business alone. You need the help of a trusted adviser to see you through the complicated process. Before you hire an expert, however, be sure to do your due diligence and determine if this person is truly working in your best interest. مصور درون

    ReplyDelete
  26. http://positivecheck.blogspot.com/2016/11/long-run-growth-in-spain-evidence-from.html

    ReplyDelete
  27. Learn the top reasons why a business plan will be rejected for funding: 1. The marketing strategy shows the business lacks competitive edge in its industry or the business lacks a robust marketing strategy and is likely to fail. 2. The management team is inadequate and in some cases lack the competencies required for business success. 3.The business strategy is unclear and/or unfocussed with the risk of exposing the funder's capital to losses. 4. Financial projections are based on a rather optimistic assumptions, which when stress-tested show that the business will fail if the most likely outcomes in the marketplace materialised. Nicolas Krafft L'Oreal

    ReplyDelete
  28. Many business owners are burned out, stressed, bored with their business, and ready to move on. Do you recognize any of these 9 common signs that it's time to sell your business? Do you have a comprehensive exit strategy in place to help you if and when you DO decide to sell? In this article, a well-known business acquisition expert tells you what to watch out for when you think you might be ready to sell your business. Nicolas Krafft

    ReplyDelete
  29. Most Coaches start out in business for reasons such as, wanting to quit their full time job and be their own boss, or they want to gain the financial and personal freedom of being an entrepreneur, they also want to help people and make a difference in their life. No matter what the reason is, being a Coach is a fantastic profession to go in. However, what many Coaches don't realize until they are in the beginning stages of their Coaching career is that starting a coaching business is not always as easy as it seems. Many Coaches struggle trying to make it work and trying to make that leap to a successful Coaching business. In this report I will share with you eleven mistakes new Coaches make that are holding them back from reaching their ultimate goal of having a successful business. Private Investigator Mississauga

    ReplyDelete
  30. It's no secret that more and more people are buying products and services on the internet because of convenience, choice, price and instant service. Starting an online business and being part of the booming e-commerce world really is easiest business to start. But why? GLD Partners

    ReplyDelete
  31. Although my area of expertise is in the Internet Marketing niche, as I was writing this article, I noticed the information would also work for traditional start up businesses as well. You will notice there are no references to Internet Marketing, etc. This is because I also wanted to share this information with anyone who is planning on starting a "traditional, brick and mortar" business. But the information contained here also applies to my friends who opt to go with the trend of online marketing as well. In this article, we focus on the initial planning steps of getting your business up and ready to open. IMDB

    ReplyDelete
  32. Having the potential to turn the sails in favour of neophytes and bring down incumbents, Digital Disruption is reshaping markets with the speed and force that has no match in history! Survivors are those businesses that are pro-actively adopting digital, but in order to thrive, they must also innovate new business models to keep pace with the digital age! Quora profile

    ReplyDelete
  33. In this highly competitive business environment, where companies look to edge past their competitors by creating a network of customers through effective services, web design and development play crucial roles in this regard. Let's take a closer look at how the two aspects of web designing and web development can help grow your business and in turn lead to increase in revenue: Multilingual Logo Design Services

    ReplyDelete
  34. 2014 is shaping up to be a banner year for baby boomer business owners who want to sell their businesses and retire. What are some of the factors that are coming together to make 2014 the "year of the seller?" If you are a baby boomer business owner who is thinking about exiting your business learn why you might want to do so this year. Yahoo Finance

    ReplyDelete
  35. If you are the owner of a plumbing company, then you are probably like many other business owners. You realize that you can't work forever. Affordable virtual assistant

    ReplyDelete
  36. If you ask anyone what kind of work they thought a Private investigator does, many people would say they were a spy for hire. Many PI's are actually ex cops or retired cops who couldn't just retire and relax or that love the work so much they started their own firm. Cops make great Private investigators because they are already trained and have experience dealing with criminals and know all the tricks of the industry. private investigator near me

    ReplyDelete
  37. It's difficult to find someone who read Missing Believed Crazy by Terence Blacker and did not enjoy reading it. The story of Missing Believed Crazy by Terence Blacker is told from the point of view of all the characters, which is quite unconventional. One page of story is told by a parent whereas the next page is told by one of the protagonists. asset search investigations

    ReplyDelete
  38. Do you want to be an Entrepreneur or a Small Business Owner? Is there a difference, and does it matter? There is a difference, and it's easy to confuse the two or use the two terms interchangeably. As you prepare to become your own boss, or if you have already started a small business, it's important to keep your long-term vision in mind. Doing so will help you determine the type of business you start and build, helping ensure that you achieve your definition of success. CPI regenerative thermal oxidizer

    ReplyDelete
  39. Quite a beautiful website. I built mine and i was looking for some design ideas and your website gave me some. Did you develop the website alone? click here

    ReplyDelete
  40. This blog consists of good information. I follow all the mentioned pointers and get away with my problem. So, if How to access old cash app account then there might be a possibility that the Cash App server may be down. If this happens, you should not worry. The cash app desk will help you to get the money that is deducted from your account. Visit Site: www.cashappdesk.com

    ReplyDelete
  41. We expect a positive leap in our client base in the following not many months, for we have incredible assumptions from the Direct Deposit include. There have been different rounds of conversation with banks from everywhere the nation to guarantee our client support arrives at an extraordinary stature for consumer loyalty. We at Cash App are focused on affecting the universe of banking to develop dramatically with our inventive arrangements.

    when does cash app direct deposit hit

    ReplyDelete
  42. For a small business to grow into a big business, it needs a loan unless it has exceptional sales and profit margins. A small business owner has quite a few places where he/she can go with a loan request. Banks seem to be one of their options on most occasions. Freedom Insurance

    ReplyDelete
  43. The purpose of this article is give you tips and strategies to help you with your new business. Although 80 percent of all new businesses fail, it's not usually due to lack of funding. It's usually comes down to knowledge, experience and leadership. Cd33 molecule

    ReplyDelete
  44. If your business is doing well in this competitive market, congratulations! You must be doing something right. The question is, is business as good as it could be? A good way to test that theory is to bring in some outside business counsel to scan the landscape and see if there is more you could do to expand and grow even more. DUI Attorney Vancouver WA

    ReplyDelete
  45. cheers for such a brilliant website. Where else could someone get that kind of information written in such a perfect way? I have a presentation that I am presently working on, and I have been on the watch out for such information. led custom signs

    ReplyDelete